[This article was originally published in two parts in Transistor Radio Collector magazine, July/August and September/October, 1997. I update it periodically as I research new material.]
The purpose of this article is to provide some background for those who are curious about how the transistor emerged from being a research laboratory experiment to a commercial marketplace reality.
Although the transistor officially celebrated its 50th anniversary in 1997 its origins go back farther than most of us generally realize. In September, 1939 two Bell Labs research scientists discovered that there were both positive (p-type) and negative (n-type) regions in a material called silicon. This research led to the recognition that semiconducting materials might have useful applications. In December, 1939 a young Bell Labs scientist named William Shockley first conceptualized a dramatic new application for semiconducting materials:
The first experimental semiconductor device was actually made of another material called germanium. A crude looking collection of wires, insulators, and germanium was demonstrated on Dec. 23, 1947, at Bell Labs by William Shockley and his research team of John Bardeen and Walter Brittain.
The name transistor (a combination of TRANSconductance varISTOR) was suggested by another Bell Labs engineer. To read the rather interesting Bell Labs memo related to naming the transistor, click here. Subsequently in 1956, Shockley, Bardeen and Brittain won a Nobel prize for their work.
The point contact transistor patent (shown below) was applied for on June 17, 1948 by John Bardeen and Walter Brattain.
William Shockley had wanted to be listed as the sole inventor for the point contact transistor. When this didn't happen he didn't waste any time filing a patent (shown below) for the junction transistor only nine days later on June 26, 1948.
The first public demonstration of the transistor was at a press conference in New York City on that same day (June 26, 1948), however it was not until five days later that a rather obscure reference to the event appeared in print. It was buried in the "News Of Radio" column on page 46 of the New York Times:
My search into the history of transistors was aided greatly by the fortunate acquisition of several periodicals from the time. In particular I was able to review almost every issue of Radio-Electronics, Radio & Television News, and Electronics Engineering from 1948 through 1953 and beyond.
Radio-Electronics first announced the transistor in September, 1948 and Hugo Gernsback followed up with one of his typical "crystal ball" type editorials in December, 1948. Interestingly, he got most of it right. Although he correctly believed the electron tube would remain dominant in high power applications he did predict such miniature devices as pen size radios, pocket recording instruments, personal military receivers, proximity fuses, and onboard airplane radar. He even wrote at great length about how performers would be able to wear transmitters which would eliminate unsightly microphone cords on stage. Remember, this was in 1948 and the transistor was less than a year old! Mr. Gernsbach seems to have been something of a visionary. His only failure was speculation about "atomic" transistors with point contacts made of radioactive material which would allow them to be self powered!
Another of the first references to this exciting new discovery in the field of semiconductors was published in the October, 1948 issue of R&TN. It was titled "A Crystal That Amplifies - details of experiments with a double-contact germanium type crystal having transconductance". Essentially this article describes how to make a point contact transistor using a chip of germanium from a 1N34 diode and cats whiskers fashioned from tube heater filament wire. An interesting sidebar reads as follows:
The first reference I have found for a commercially available transistor appeared in the January, 1950 issue of R-E. Amazingly it was a construction article for building a three transistor radio using CK703's as shown in figure 4 below. The article also described plans for constructing transistor sockets since they were not yet available commercially.
Interestingly there was no reference as to the source or price of the CK703. As shown a little further below the CK703 was almost $20 each so the cost of transistors alone would have made this set an unobtainable dream for most hobbyists.
In the May, 1950 issue of R-E was an article discussing an oscillator
circuit which was designed using a Raytheon CK703 point contact transistor
or "crystal triode". The June, 1950 issue of R-E carried another article
with circuit applications for the CK703. The device measured about 5/8"
long and 1/4" in diameter. A paper label bearing the Raytheon logo and
type number was attached for identification.
I am indebted to a friend, Allan Pellnat, who shared a considerable
amount of information regarding the commercial availability and pricing
of early transistors. Allan provided an image of the first transistor advertisment
he has found. It was in the 1950-51 isssue of the Radio Master catalog.
The solitary listing was for the Raytheon CK703 and it was priced at $18.00.
For a reality check, an $18.00 transistor in 1951 would be around $110.00
today after taking inflation into account. Because of manufacturing difficulties
at this early stage of development (and obviously its high cost), the CK703
was not produced or used in significant numbers. Most likely it remained
a laboratory curiousity.
The next transistor product announcement I could find appeared in the September, 1950 issue of R-E. It was for the GE type SX-4A and Z-2 point contact devices which were built to "joint Army-Navy specifications". Again this appears to be earlier than the general Bell Labs licensing announcement but since the application was apparently military in nature that may be the explanation.
As transistor research progressed a new variation was developed. The August, 1951 issue of R-E reported that Bell Labs had announced on July 5th a junction type transistor. Two advantages of junction transistors were reported to be a significantly lower noise figure coupled with higher gain. The article concluded with the news that development of the point contact transistor had reached such a stable level that they would be put to trial use in Bell Telephone System equipment early the following year (1952).
Hugo Gernsbach wrote another interesting editorial in R-E in December, 1951 in which he praised the advantages of the transistor. Although they had many advantages over vacuum tubes he noted that several problems would preclude transistors from replacing tubes for many years. For instance the transistor at that time was still limited in its high frequency response, and many "bugs" remained which prevented its mass production. Perhaps the most significant item was the transistor's economic disadvantage. He reported that the devices cost about $18.00 each at that time. Based on the information reported above it can be safely assumed he was referring to the Raytheon CK703. He ended the editorial with the following bizarre observation:
In 1952 Bell Labs began licensing its new invention to interested companies for a fee of $25,000. Among the first to take advantage of this were General Electric, IBM, Raytheon, a new company called Texas Instruments, and a small Japanese company that eventually became Sony Electronics.
Although amateur radio operators used transistors to design experimental radio circuits as early as 1950, this was the exception and not the rule. During that early period some Bell Labs engineers made a wrist radio "in their spare time" as a gift for cartoonist Chester Gould, the creator of cartoon character Dick Tracy, who had used such a fictional device in the comics for many years. The radio case measured 1 1/2" x 2" x 3/4", however the external components included a 1" lapel speaker, the battery, and an antenna wire. Radio-Electronics (R-E) magazine reported in September, 1952:
By mid 1952 research and development had come a long way. Dr. Lee De Forest, the inventor of the triode vacuum tube in 1906, wrote an article for R-E in July, 1952 about the future of transistors. The majority of his predictions, as viewed from our vantage point in time, have been met. Many of the advantages he listed are things that we take for granted today; that transistors would likely replace tubes in applications requiring long life, low power, and small size. Specifically mentioned were hearing ai ds, proximity fuses (for bombs), and self guiding missiles. It must be remembered that transistor development was seen as a priority by the military during the cold war build up in the early 1950's. This undoubtedly hastened their acceptance for use in all areas of electronics.
In terms of consumer goods, perhaps the following observation by Dr. De Forest is the most pertinent for today, considering the vast numbers of personal computers.
In the area of personal entertainment devices he correctly predicted:
Also in the July, 1952 issue of R-E was an article on transistor production. It noted that most transistors being made were of the point-contact type. Western Electric was the only manufacturer producing junction devices, and then only on an experimental basis at the rate of less than 100 per month.
Popular Science magazine published what may be the first ever transistor radio construction article entitled "Now You Can Build a Transistor Radio", in its October, 1952 issue. It is also fascinating in that it is the only article of this type that I have seen which uses point contact transistors! The author states that the Western Electric A-1698 devices could be purchased for $6.50 apiece from WECO in Allentown, PA. Based on other prices at that time this appears to be a real bargain. In reality WECO was probably just selling "factory seconds" which didn't meet the high standards required for use in the Bell Telephone System. The three transistor circuit was very simple and used one transistor as the detector. The other two provided audio amplification. If you didn't want to wait for the proper Cinch transistor sockets you could build your own using automobile fuse holders and spring brass to make clips for the two leads. The article cautioned, "Don't solder leads directly to the (transistor) prongs. The heat will ruin the crystal".
A true milestone in transistor history occurred during the month of October, 1952 when the Bell Telephone System placed the very first transistorized equipment in the world into commercial service in Englewood, New Jersey. Point contact transistors were used to replace vacuum tubes in the oscillator circuits which generated signals that allowed 10,000 customers to personally dial long distance calls without the assistance of an operator. Other equipment soon followed and included rural telephone carrier amplifiers and headset amplifiers for operators.
The major manufacturers in late 1952 were, in order of monthly production levels: Western Electric - 6,000, Raytheon - 1,000, General Electric - 800, and RCA - 400. Delivery times were from 4 to 8 weeks and Raytheon, GE, and RCA were projecting that sample lots of junction type transistors would be available by December, 1952.
Production limitations were still hampering the widespread use of transistors and their high price remained a major barrier. The first transistors offered for sale by Allied Radio appeared on page 55 of their 1953 catalog. Both were point contact devices, the Raytheon CK716 (successor to the CK703) for $18.00 and the General Electric G11 and G11A for $17.40 each. Only the most dedicated and wealthy of hobbyists could hope to afford the luxury of experimenting with their own personal transistor, not to mention taking the risk of burning it up!
Raytheon subsequently became the first manufacturer to mass-produce junction transistors. The first product announcement I have found is in the January, 1953 issue of the IRE Proceedings. It showed both the CK722 and CK721 devices and stated that the CK722 was available in production quantities, while the CK721 would only be available in limited quantities until April. Photographic date code evidence suggests that these devices were being made as early as late 1952 although these may have simply been pre-production samples. The differences between the CK721 and CK722 will be discussed later.
A February, 1953 editorial in R-E stated that:
R-E reported in March, 1953 that completely transistorized hearing aids had been offered to the public for the first time. One of the pioneering companies was named Maico and they offered a three transistor unit called the "Transist-Ear" which was later described in some detail in the December, 1953 issue of R-E. Its dimensions were only 2 5/8" x 1 7/8" x 13/16" and it weighed only two ounces. Power was supplied by a 1.5 volt mercury cell which had an estimated life of 70 - 90 hours. The transistors were special (read expensive) Raytheon CK718 germanium types made especially for the hearing aid industry. Due to the wide variation of characteristics in early mass-produced junction transistors, the biasing resistors in the common emitter circuit design had to be matched to each transistor. This essentially amounted to each hearing aid being a custom-made device! The article noted:
Despite these difficulties, the advantages in size, expected useful life and minimal power requirements clinched the transistor's superiority over vacuum tubes.
Raytheon announced a transistor application contest with $10,000 in prizes in the June, 1953 issues of both CQ and R-E magazine. 1st prize was $5,000, 2nd $2,000, 3rd $1,000, 4th $500, 5th $300, and 6th to 17th $100. The contest closed at midnight on August 31, 1953.
I have examples of at least three case variations which were made over the production life of the CK722. Despite the differences which will be described below, they are all based on a distinctively shaped small rectangular block about 1/4" wide x 1/8" deep x 1/2" high. The three wire leads are evenly spaced and the collector is identified by a red dot on the side of the case.
The first CK722's (from late 1952 through at least part of 1954) were made of a black plastic with sharply defined edges and a clear glass base. These early units were not hermetically sealed in a metal case, but Frank Dukat of Raytheon remembers that the plastic encapsulation was "airtight" since moisture and contamination would cause failure. Moisture was a greater problem for grown junction transistors as opposed to the alloy junctions which Raytheon made. The lettering was white and the production date can be determined from a 3 digit code printed on the case. The format is YWW where Y=last digit of year and WW=week of the year. For the black units the date is printed on the back of the case. I have a "3-32" which would be 32nd week of 1953 (August) and a "416" which would be the 16th week of 1954 (April). Several R-E construction articles also support this format and clearly show two CK722's with date codes of 250 and 334. Another article shows two CK718's with codes of 245. My earliest junction transistor is a Raytheon CK721 dated 309 or the ninth week of 1953.
The first variation of the CK722 was being made by 1955 and it had a beautiful deep blue painted metal case with a slightly more rounded appearance on the edges. It was also hermetically sealed and had white lettering. These units have the date code printed perpendicular to the leads just above the case bottom on the same side as the type number and Raytheon name. Otherwise the format is the same.
The third and final CK722 variation I am aware of is almost identical to the blue jobs except that the case appears to be unpainted aluminum and has black lettering. I have examples of these from 1960 and 1963. Sometime after 1960 the date code format changed to YYWW. My 1963 device is marked "6352" which is the last week of 1963. Frank Dukat remembers that the final Raytheon CK722's were made in late 1964 or early 1965 when they closed their Lewiston, Maine plant and ceased manufacturing germanium devices.
Frank also recalled the following interesting information. As time went on and technology allowed transistors to became smaller, Raytheon still had to maintain the originally registered case size for the CK722 and its close family. The later transistors were actually much smaller and were simply inserted into dummy cases of the correct larger size! According to Frank if you cut one of the later ones open you will find a much smaller one intact inside. I have verified this to be true.
The September, 1953 issue of R-E carried a construction article for a simple hearing aid housed in a metal cigarette case. It was based on commercial products but used the popular CK722 transistors instead of CK718's or CK721's which were a higher grade and thus more expensive and less available to the private experimenter. One compromise was the necessity of using a 15 volt battery instead of a 1.5 volt one. Another caution was:
An interesting discussion of the production variations in small signal PNP junction transistors was written by F. M. Dukat of the Raytheon Manufacturing Company in the September, 1953 issue of Radio-Electronic Engineering magazine.
1. Presently available transistors are quite variable in characteristics, and although more is being learned daily about control, units must still be selected after manufacture.
2. Some form of d.c. compensation is almost mandatory to control operating points.
3. Although the highest gains are available in the grounded emitter amplifier connection, the spread of gain in the grounded base amplifier is less.
4. Designs for transistor amplifiers for production purposes would do well to sacrifice appreciable stage gain by suitable feedback in order to reduce unit to unit variability."
Further clarification of the transistor's importance was provided in the November, 1953 issue of R&T News.
A November, 1954 R-E news item recognized the following achievement:
A July, 1955 R-E news item quotes the lowest Raytheon transistor price as being $1.70 in large quantities, down about half from the year before. The hobbyist could also purchase single CK722 transistors through various mail order distributors. The first Lafayette Radio ad in R-E to feature transistors included the CK722 and appeared in the July, 1955 issue. They were priced at $2.45 each (or $2.25 ea for 10 or more). A price of $2.45 in 1955 would be roughly equal to $15.00 today.
Prices continued to plunge dramatically over the next few months as production increased. An August, 1955 Lafayette ad lists the CK722 for $2.10 each (or $1.95 ea for 10 or more). The GE 2N107 was listed as NEW and was $1.25 each. The November, 1955 Lafayette ad showed both the CK722 and 2N107 at $1.25 each.
By December, 1955 Lafayette was selling the CK722 for $.99 each. Only seven years had passed since the transistor was born in 1947 and it was now ready to break into the mainstream of American manufacturing technology.
It is easy to forget just how close we are to transistors in our daily lives, but we are rarely more than a foot or two away from them. Although they are no longer typically used as discrete components, they hide by the millions inside tiny integrated circuits in computers, watches, radios, automobiles, and other items too numerous to mention. Our world would be a very different place today without this amazing little device. The invention of the transistor has truly had a profound effect on the course o f civilization during the past fifty years and its influence will continue into the future.
--
References:
Radio-Electronics (R-E) magazine - January, 1952 to December, 1955
QST magazine - May, 1953
CQ magazine - May & June, 1953
LIFE magazine - April, 1953
Texas Instruments Internet Web site
Lucent Technologies (former Bell Labs) Internet Web site
Email interview with Mr. Frank M. Dukat, retired employee of Raytheon,
March, 1999
Exhibit 1
The Original Press Release On The Regency Radio
DALLAS, Texas
October 18, 1954
TI Supplying Transistors for First "Pocket Size" Radio
TI's part in the production of the first commercial transistorized radio receiver will be announced beginning today in newspapers throughout the country.
The "pocket size" radio has four TI transistors. It also uses a TI sub miniature output transformer.
The transistors - technically known as n-p-n grown junction germanium triodes - are made in the Semiconductor Products Division. The transformer is a product of the Components Division.
Their application to the new radio receiver accounts for a large part of the increased production and employment in the two divisions in recent weeks. The Apparatus Division has also had a hand in the tiny radio, having worked on engineering problems and the machining and fabricating of models for the plastic case.
The receiver is being assembled and marketed by the Regency Division of Industrial Development Engineering Associates, Inc., Indianapolis. It will be available this week to the public through sales outlets in Los Angeles and New York City. When production permits, it will be sold in cities throughout the country. For competitive reasons it was decided to keep the development of the radio, including TI's part in it, "under wraps" until the unit was ready for marketing.
The radio receiver measures 5 x 3 x 1 1/4 inches - the smallest set commercially available - with the semiconductor devices themselves occupying less than 1/10 of a cubic inch. The "pocket size" is a significant achievement since it includes a high fidelity, high volume speaker and a single battery supply as well as all associated receiver circuit components.
Gain at radio frequency with the germanium transistor is sufficient to permit a combined mixer-oscillator stage. Only two intermediate frequency stages are required and, following a germanium diode detector, one audio amplifier stage. Audio volume fidelity and reception range are the equal of or superior to that of the small vacuum tube-equipped portable radios.
The introduction of this first mass production item to use the tiny transistor to replace the fragile vacuum tube leads the way for the long-predicted transistorization and miniaturization of many other mass production consumer devices. TIers can justly be proud of being the first to produce a high-gain transistor at a cost permitting its application to the high-volume commercial market.
Transistor Manufacturer Comments on New Radio
Dallas, TX
October 18, 1954
Following the announcement today of the first commercial transistorized radio receiver, Executive Vice-President P.E. Haggerty of Texas Instruments Incorporated--leading transistor manufacturer--issued a statement of congratulations to the Regency company on its significant electronic achievement.
In a message to Mr. Edward C. Tudor, President of Industrial Development Engineering Associates, Inc., Mr. Haggerty said, "As the transistor manufacturer, we sincerely congratulate your Regency division on being the first to produce commercially a transistorized consumer product. With the introduction of this first mass production item replacing the fragile vacuum tube with the tiny transistor, Electronics enters a new era," Mr. Haggerty continued.
Texas Instruments--manufacturer of the new low cost, high gain transistor, which makes the first commercial transistorized radio possible--is one of the largest producers of germanium transistors and the exclusive producer of silicon transistors for high temperature applications. Its latest development, the low cost, high gain transistor used in the Regency radio, is one of the greatest practical advances yet made in transistor technology since it makes possible the long predicted transistorization and m iniaturization of mass production consumer devices.
"We are proud to have contributed to Regency's pioneering achievement." Mr. Haggerty continued. "Production of a high gain transistor at reasonable cost has been a long-sought goal of the entire Electronics industry. The Regency company deserves special commendation for the remarkable speed with which it converted this latest transistor development into a superior, marketable product," he concluded.
Kernel-sized substitutes for vacuum tubes in electronic amplifying, until now transistors have been limited in consumer application. The largest commercial application for transistors has been in hearing aids, in which the benefits of miniaturization, long battery life and high reliability have justified their use. Texas Instruments has been an important supplier of transistors for hearing aids, as well as for many specialized commercial and military applications.
The new Texas Instruments low cost, high gain transistors used in the revolutionary new Regency pocket receiver are technically termed n-p-n grown junction, germanium triodes. Such a high gain is obtained with the new transistors--up to 40 decibels per stage--that only four are required by the radio.
Even so, audio volume fidelity, and reception range are the equal of or superior to that of the small vacuum tube-equipped portable radios. Grown junction construction--wherein the germanium crystal layers of dissimilar electrical characteristics are grown into the transistor--contributes to the transistor's performance and reliability.
The Regency radio is made possible by an efficient circuit design taking full advantage of the unique features of the new Texas Instruments low cost, high gain, high frequency transistor in combination with the advantages common to all transistors. Gain at radio frequency is sufficient with the new transistor so that one transistor is used for a combined mixer-oscillator stage. Only two intermediate frequency stages are required and, following a germanium diode detector, one audio amplifier stage.
The first completely transistorized commercial broadcast receiver has a resulting "form factor" of 5 x 3 x 1-1/4 inches--the smallest compete set commercially available--with the semiconductor devices themselves occupying less than 1/10 of a cubic inch. The "pocket size" is considered a significant achievement, since it includes a high fidelity, high volume speaker and single battery power supply as well as all associated receiver circuit components. The subminiature output transformer is also of Texas I nstruments manufacture.
Now that the low cost, high gain transistor has made possible the first mass production transistorized device, Texas Instruments anticipates that the resultant increase in transistor production will make economically feasible the transistorization of many more consumer products. TI predicts that the first commercial production of a low cost, high gain germanium transistor will rank in importance with the first commercial production of the high temperature, high frequency silicon transistor...also exclusive to Texas Instruments.
Return to transistor page